Is the hydrogen tech ‘revolution’ hope or hype?

Is the hydrogen tech 'revolution' hope or hype?


Picture caption

Diggers are actually one of many car varieties powered by hydrogen

In his speech on the deliberate financial restoration, the prime minister stated hydrogen know-how is an space the place the UK leads the world. He hopes it’ll create clear jobs sooner or later. However is the hydrogen revolution hope or hype?

The digger with the long-toothed bucket bites right into a pile of stones, tilts up and flexes its sturdy mechanical arm.

It swivels, extends the arm and dumps its load on the tough floor of a Staffordshire quarry.

It’s a beast of a machine and from the entrance it appears like a traditional excavator.

However from the again you possibly can see its tank filled with soiled diesel has been changed with a hydrogen gas cell.

The excavator is the most recent in a technology of autos powered by the lightest component on Earth.

The compendium of autos powered by hydrogen now stretches from diggers to micro-taxis, vehicles, boats, vans, single-deck and now double-decker buses – and even small planes.

It really works by reacting hydrogen with oxygen in a gas cell to generate electrical energy. The one direct emission is water.

Speaking a couple of revolution

So ultimately, the long-awaited hydrogen revolution is right here. Or is it?

Again within the early 2000s, backers of hydrogen thought it might dominate the clear vehicle market.

However the promised “hydrogen freeway” by no means materialised, for a few essential causes.

Firstly, hydrogen energy wanted a brand new infrastructure, whereas rival battery vehicles could possibly be charged off the near-ubiquitous electrical energy grid.

Secondly, high-powered batteries at the moment had been already well-advanced for different makes use of comparable to computer systems, however hydrogen was not.

Picture copyright

Picture caption

Can hydrogen vehicles nonetheless grow to be a dominant pressure?

So hydrogen misplaced the head-on battle for the motor automobile. However now it’s again within the body for the kind of transport, business and heating duties that batteries are struggling to fulfil.

Take our giant mechanical digger, a prototype from JCB. It has a bit of battery-powered cousin – sufficiently small to squeeze by means of a doorway and work in a constructing.

However JCB say the massive digger would want a battery weighing 5 tonnes, and take hours to refuel. Hydrogen then again, is lighter than air and takes minutes to fill a tank.

Lorries fall into the identical class as diggers – generally the battery could be as heavy because the payload.

Double deckers

The identical applies to buses, and the Bamford household, which owns JCB, says it has orders for 80 double-deck buses from its Wrightbus manufacturing facility at Ballymena in Northern Eire.

That also leaves the difficulty of charging infrastructure – however that may be solved by offering hydrogen pumps on motorways for long-distance truckers.

The identical community may gas hybrid battery and hydrogen vehicles of the longer term and dispense with the necessity for ever-heavier batteries in plug-in vehicles.

Buses may use hydrogen saved at depots in Kevlar-lined tanks for security.

Previous fears of hydrogen tanks exploding have been addressed by the appearance of tanks lined with Kevlar and hydrogen launch mechanisms in case the tank is struck.

Taking off

Airports may additionally retailer hydrogen, and the primary take a look at flight of an electrical airplane within the UK at Cranfield College just lately was powered by a hydrogen gas cell.

There’s – forgive the pun – a head of steam constructing over hydrogen. Germany is racing forward with a community of filling stations and a hydrogen practice. It’s investing E7bn in a bid to dominate the hydrogen market.

The EU Fee needs a slice of the motion, too.

Picture caption

Hydrogen trains are additionally being examined

The web site Euractiv reported that it plans to publish a hydrogen technique quickly. A leaked draft floated the concept of constructing the Euro the foreign money for worldwide hydrogen trades, because the US Greenback is for oil.

The UK authorities additionally intends to announce a hydrogen technique earlier than the Parliament closes for the summer season, as a part of its financial restoration bundle.

It’s being spurred on by rebukes that the UK misplaced the battle for battery know-how to China – so it mustn’t let the hydrogen bandwagon escape. The federal government is suggested by its Committee on Local weather Change to start out large-scale trials within the early 2020s.

Certainly, inside weeks from now, Britain’s first hydrogen practice – developed by Birmingham College – will likely be examined on common tracks.

So it appears as if hydrogen has lastly made it. However not so quick… as a result of it’s under no circumstances trouble-free.

Presently virtually all of the hydrogen bought within the UK is produced by splitting it from pure fuel. However that’s expensive and emits a lot of planet-heating carbon dioxide.

The issue might be tackled by capturing the CO2 at a hydrogen manufacturing hub, then burying it with carbon seize and storage. However that may drive the price up additional.

The choice is inherently clear – however very costly. It entails utilizing surplus renewable electrical energy, like when the wind blows at evening, to separate hydrogen from water utilizing a gas cell.

Idiot cells?

The method is wasteful as a result of it entails turning electrical energy right into a fuel, then again into electrical energy – a two-step shuffle dismissed by Tesla automobile chief Elon Musk as “staggeringly dumb”. “Idiot cells”, he calls them.

However hydrogen-lovers consider the longer term electrical energy grid will produce a lot low-cost off-peak energy that we’ll want to seek out different makes use of for it. And so they hope to see the price of gas cells plummet following the instance of offshore wind.

Picture copyright

Picture caption

Elon Musk has been dismissive about hydrogen gas cell know-how

Actually, current occasions have favoured the advance of hydrogen. When the UK had a goal of 80% carbon cuts by 2050, that left leeway for polluting types of gas to take up the remaining 20% of the carbon “price range”.

Now it’s extensively accepted that houses with low-carbon heating programs comparable to warmth exchangers will want a lift in a chilly snap from one other supply – and that’s wanting more and more like hydrogen.

Trials are already underway utilizing hydrogen blended into pure fuel at Keele College.

And, relying on how a lot assist it will get from the federal government – it appears as if a know-how that misplaced its key battle in opposition to battery vehicles 20 years in the past will nonetheless discover a place within the zero-carbon financial system of tomorrow.

Comply with Roger on Twitter.

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.