The day the worldwide tax authorities got here knocking

The day the international tax authorities came knocking

On a sunny Friday in late January, investigators from the Australian Tax Workplace issued subpoenas and fired off letters as a part of an unprecedented probe that reached world wide.

It was an identical scene in Amsterdam, the place investigators from the Dutch tax company set a few related job. So, too, did investigators in the US, Canada and the UK.

Whereas not one of the millionaire tax dodgers focused on January 24, together with about 100 Australians, knew one another, they shared a bond: they had been prospects of a little-known Caribbean financial institution.

The Euro Pacific Financial institution in Puerto Rico’s capital San Juan was based by American celeb investor and enterprise commentator Peter Schiff. The silver-haired and pugnacious businessman is price an estimated $100 million. On main tv networks, well-liked podcasts and his personal YouTube channel, he reminds his viewers he predicted the World Monetary Disaster. He additionally likes to warn individuals in regards to the upcoming financial apocalypse from which they will take monetary refuge in his “privateness assured” financial institution.

Banker Peter Schiff.

Banker Peter Schiff.Credit score:Channel 9

Schiff’s celeb standing is probably going why some main Australian monetary establishments, together with Westpac and the Perth Mint, hopped into mattress with the Euro Pacific Financial institution. They weren’t alone. The New York Federal Reserve and Canada’s Financial institution of Montreal each allowed their prospects to switch funds into the financial institution, cloaking it in an air of credibility it used to draw hundreds of shoppers, together with at the least 400 from Australia (about 100 are thought of “excessive threat”).

However on January 24, Euro Pacific turned the goal of Operation Atlantis, the world’s largest tax evasion probe. Australia’s deputy tax commissioner, Will Day, describes the inquiry as “unprecedented”.

An investigation by The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and 60 Minutes in collaboration with The New York Instances can reveal that Operation Atlantis is analyzing the monetary transactions of Euro Pacific’s prospects. Lots of of account holders are actually suspects in a tax evasion probe.

Among the many tremendous rich Australians suspected to have sought to maintain their monetary affairs secret is the Sydney businessman answerable for considered one of Australia’s largest tax rorts, Simon Anquetil. Different Australian account holders embody Darby Angel, a Hollywood movie financier with a drug-trafficking conviction.

Simon Anquetil in happier days.

Simon Anquetil in happier days.

If Euro Pacific is the suspected coronary heart of a shady monetary system, its companions akin to Westpac and the Perth Mint are the veins. Regardless of the raids, Euro Pacific continues to be, for now, pumping suspected tax-lite {dollars} world wide. And in an interview, Schiff says he intends to maintain it that method.

Like father, like son

A dislike of paying tax is a Schiff household trait. Peter Schiff’s father, Irwin, is seen as a martyr of the tax resistance motion. He ran a enterprise known as Freedom Books from a Las Vegas store entrance, promoting data packages that taught hundreds of Individuals how one can cheat the system. He died in jail for tax evasion.

Schiff has inherited his father’s love of profile. He spends hours every week recording his web present, speaking about every part from inflation and gold to the “faux information” of white privilege. However whereas Irwin opened a bookshop, his son opened an offshore financial institution in sunny Puerto Rico – a US territory within the Caribbean which gives low to zero tax charges for eligible companies and residents.

It was January 2017, virtually three years to the day earlier than the ATO started knocking on doorways, when Schiff and accomplice Mark Anderson filed into the Division de Estado – a pale-blue Spanish colonial-style constructing with two Puerto Rican flags adorning the entrance entrance — to signal paperwork registering their new enterprise.

The financial institution’s new workplace is on the tenth ground of a blue-glass block that overlooks the North Atlantic Ocean. It’s within the costly a part of San Juan. However former workers talking on the situation anonymity say the workplace was a bit just like the financial institution itself. “An empty shell that has the looks of luxurious,” based on one Puerto Rican who labored there. “It was mainly empty aside from just a few desks, chairs and the computer systems.”

Colourful houses line the hillside over looking the beach in San Juan, Puerto Rico. 

Vibrant homes line the hillside over trying the seaside in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Credit score:Shutterstock

When it opened in San Juan, Euro Pacific was considered one of 81 offshore banks on the island and it will grow to be by far the most important. Authorities information from the time of registration present the financial institution had 13,000 buyer accounts and greater than $232 million in deposits. Schiff himself lives there with all the trimmings of colonial luxurious.

Offshore accounts can have respectable functions. For instance, they will maintain cash for multi-national companies. However former Australian Federal Police officer and monetary crime knowledgeable John Chevis has additionally seen them used to stash untaxed and undeclared revenue, aided by bankers who, even when they might not have direct data of what their prospects are as much as, are keen to take advantage of authorized loopholes.

“You would need to query why somebody would place their cash in a jurisdiction that is so far-off, in a financial institution that does not pay any curiosity, in a financial institution that costs monumental charges for shifting your cash,” Chevis stated.

Euro Pacific’s former IT director, John Ogilvie, additionally had questions after working on the financial institution in 2014-16. Ogilvie says he was confronted with a shambolic enterprise, lax information safety and high-risk shoppers. He suspected some Australians had been opening up accounts to keep away from the ATO.

The financial institution’s safety was additionally an issue. Anderson’s laptop was hacked thrice over a two-year interval, Ogilvie says, and at one level, Russians tried to extort the financial institution for a ransom of 1000 bitcoins, price thousands and thousands of {dollars}. Ogilvie says prospects from Australia and elsewhere in search of to maintain their financial institution accounts secret had been as a substitute liable to having their monetary affairs floating across the darkish net.

Former AFP organised crime investigator John Chevis.

Former AFP organised crime investigator John Chevis.

Recruiting prospects was a relentless job executed by “onboarders”. 5 of them, talking on the situation of anonymity, declare they went by way of an inconsistent vetting course of that ranged from a fast Google and social media examine “to ensure they had been an actual individual” to, in some instances, a extra thorough sequence of checks.

“There’s an enormous disconnect between what you’re taught and what you do,” says one ex-employee.

Euro Pacific’s anti-money laundering efforts had been additionally seen sceptically by a few of the giant corporations it was courting. Mastercard rejected the financial institution’s software for a licence round 2017 after it failed to fulfill anti-money laundering requirements, leaving many shoppers with out debit playing cards. By 2018, destructive suggestions in regards to the financial institution was circulating on-line, and functions for brand spanking new accounts began to dry up. On the San Juan workplace, the kitchen stopped being crammed with espresso and snacks.

By then, Ogilvie had been sacked over a disagreement with senior administration. After two years at Euro Pacific, his final act was to ship an e mail to Peter Schiff.

“The chickens will come residence to roost,” Ogilvie wrote. “You’ll have to cope with the issues inside Euro Pacific Financial institution Ltd. sooner or later.”

The Australian connection

What most of us know in regards to the world of worldwide tax avoidance comes from the publicity of Panamanian legislation agency Mossack Fonseca which organized for the ultra-wealthy to cover their monetary affairs in tax havens.

However the “Panama Papers” scandal had one other profound impact. It uncovered tax authorities as flat-footed and reactive. Within the months after the leak in 2016, senior investigators from Australia’s tax workplace and prison intelligence fee proposed their very own community of world investigators. With minimal fanfare, a taskforce known as the “Joint 5” was created in 2018, comprising the 5 chiefs of tax companies in Australia, the US, UK, Canada and the Netherlands.

Australian Tax Office investigator Will Day.

Australian Tax Workplace investigator Will Day.Credit score:Alex Ellinghausen

Mimicking the 5 Eyes spy alliance, the Australian “J5” chief Will Day says he and the guy tax sleuths started trying to find snippets of economic intelligence that might open up a “chink within the armour” of secretive offshore banks.

“There’s all the time a hint for us to select up on and that may be by way of our personal covert operations, it may be from an investor coming ahead,” says Day.

Day agreed to be interviewed on the situation he wouldn’t identify any entity or particular person. He’s very cautious. However he confirms the J5 chiefs started attempting to find the form of leaked information that knowledgeable the Panama Papers. He additionally confirms the title of the J5’s largest investigation: Atlantis — the identify of a mythic Greek island.

And the chink within the armour that triggered Atlantis?

Based on a supply with involvement within the abroad operations of the tax probe, a leak of the account particulars of hundreds of Euro Pacific prospects opened up traces of inquiry. As soon as the J5 had the data, buyer names had been matched towards prison databases held by police and tax companies across the globe, together with revenue tax declarations. The data revealed Euro Pacific’s prospects included entities linked to a who’s who of economic and organised crime. Amongst them was Sydney businessman Simon Anquetil, the mastermind behind Australia’s largest tax fraud, Plutus Payroll.

Simon Anquetil during his Plutus Payroll days.

Simon Anquetil throughout his Plutus Payroll days.

The Plutus fraud, hatched in 2014, began as a payroll companies firm however morphed right into a scheme that stole thousands and thousands of {dollars} from the tax workplace that paid for quick automobiles and glitzy occasions graced by the likes of Miss World Australia. By the point police arrested Anquetil in Might 2017, they estimated he had stolen greater than $105 million.

Sources say one other of Euro Pacific’s account holders is Australian entrepreneur and Hollywood movie financier, Darby Angel.

Angel first appeared in public information in 1996 when he was convicted within the Melbourne Magistrates Court docket of drug trafficking.

When approached for this story, Angel was fast to contact the identical lawyer who represented him again in 1996 – Melbourne’s Bernie Balmer, the gruff-speaking defence lawyer who goes by the identify Bernie the Lawyer. Angel stated he’d by no means heard of the financial institution and denied any involvement in wrongdoing exterior of his historic drug conviction. It should be a case of stolen id, he stated.

Entrepreneur Darby Angel.

Entrepreneur Darby Angel.

Years of labor forward

A global buyer was Canadian nationwide Gunnar Helgason, who in 2013 was arrested and deported by Thai authorities because the mastermind of “a global boiler-room rip-off”. Helgason was blamed within the media for stealing $50 million from Australians between 2008 and 2013 however was by no means charged.

His company checking account at Euro Pacific was linked to a Seychelles firm created to export furnishings, he says. The financial institution by no means requested him about his previous, Helgason says, solely a number of normal check-the-box questions.

“Nobody at Euro Pacific Financial institution stated: ‘Can we’ve got a duplicate of your most modern CV? And by the way in which, do not depart something out’,” he remembers.

The FBI additionally linked an account at Euro Pacific to a Russian syndicate described by the FBI because the world’s worst cyber crime group.

It is going to take years for investigators to work by way of the financial institution’s hundreds of shoppers. Some could also be respectable. Others not. Of the 100 or extra Australian prospects, one was John Clark.

Clark was a fan of Schiff’s podcast and shared his fears the financial system would quickly collapse. The 65-year-old says he’s labored arduous all his life and needed to safe his property. In 2014, stashing some money in an offshore financial institution backed by gold seemed like the suitable possibility. He says no authorities have gotten in contact, however he now plans to shut the account.

“It appeared like a good suggestion on the time. Nothing sinister to be sincere. It was simple placing the cash in, I wager it’ll be rather a lot more durable pulling it out,” says Clark.

The veins

Will Day from the ATO says Operation Atlantis targets worldwide cash laundering and tax evasion. The January 24 raids, he says, had been the primary time within the historical past of tax enforcement that investigators world wide had concurrently launched actions to disrupt and gather proof about an offshore financial institution.

Sources conscious of the abroad raids have confirmed that British tax authorities arrested a Euro Pacific shopper and issued warrants to a number of banks coping with Euro Pacific. In Canada, referral brokers had been approached and interviewed. In America, the IRS intercepted Schiff and Anderson for questioning.

Day received’t focus on these actions however he’ll admit to “a sense of pleasure”. So far as worldwide monetary crime probes go, he says, Operation Atlantis was “unprecedented”.

The operation must “disrupt the operations of this explicit monetary establishment”, however Day additionally stresses he’s circling “these professionals who may be eager about connecting their shoppers to those types of preparations”.

The J5 can also be looking the legal professionals, accountants and monetary establishments linking taxpayers to Peter Schiff’s financial institution.

Euro Pacific wouldn’t survive if not for the large and small gamers that make up the monetary ecosystem supporting it. Referral brokers, together with legal professionals and accountants, direct their shoppers to the financial institution in return for a fee or shopper payment.

One among Euro Pacific’s key Australian promoters is lawyer Patrick Flynn. He fairly lawfully recommends his shoppers to the financial institution, saying its most important advantage is that it refuses to robotically share data with abroad tax authorities. Flynn additionally guarantees to assist preserve legislation enforcement away from his shoppers’ monetary affairs through the use of financial institution accounts linked to firm constructions in a number of offshore jurisdictions.

Lawyer Patrick Flynn.

Lawyer Patrick Flynn.Credit score:Screenshot

“Within the occasion of a lawsuit or tax investigation or regulatory inquiry, your shopper can swear beneath oath ‘I’m not the authorized or helpful proprietor of this firm (which may very well be the distinction between being charged with/jailed for tax evasion and strolling away a free man)’,” he tells shoppers.

Flynn stated in an announcement that he helped shoppers with “respectable industrial and fiduciary constructions” with greater than 50 banks world wide. He added: “[We] don’t help shoppers to evade taxes. As far as we’re conscious, no shopper of our agency has ever been accused of, not to mention convicted of, tax evasion.”

In 2017, former AFP monetary crime investigator John Chevis found that the West Australian government-owned Perth Mint was working with Euro Pacific.

“I used to be very stunned,” Chevis says. “I believe there is a important threat that a few of the gold held throughout the Perth Mint by prospects of the Euro Pacific Financial institution could also be held beneficially for criminals in different elements of the world.”

Gold bars at the Perth Mint.

Gold bars on the Perth Mint.

The mint, which is assured by the WA authorities, is the biggest refiner of newly mined gold on the earth. Schiff’s ultra-bearish funding type has inspired hundreds of shoppers to pour cash into the valuable steel. Euro Pacific prospects may purchase bars of gold by way of the financial institution and, at one stage, its debit playing cards had been supposedly backed by the Perth Mint’s gold.

The Perth Mint was additionally probed by the ATO in January, sources with data of the raids say. The corporate refused to touch upon its relationship with Euro Pacific. Nevertheless, shortly after this masthead requested about its relationship with the Puerto Rican financial institution, the years-long relationship was severed.

Chevis says Westpac faces an identical questions. For years, Westpac was Euro Pacific’s correspondent financial institution in Australia, enabling it to ship and obtain Australian funds in return for a small payment and entry to Euro Pacific’s shoppers.

These partnerships have precipitated complications for the nation’s oldest financial institution. In November, the monetary crimes watchdog discovered Westpac didn’t correctly monitor transactions associated to 16 of its correspondent financial institution companions. The failure precipitated it to breach anti-money laundering legal guidelines 23 million occasions with some funds linked to reside baby intercourse reveals within the Philippines. Westpac has now agreed to pay the biggest effective in Australian company historical past: $1.3 billion.

However Euro Pacific was not one of many correspondent banks singled out within the motion by the regulator.

Westpac had connections with Euro Pacific Bank until 2018.

Westpac had connections with Euro Pacific Financial institution till 2018.

A former Westpac worker who labored within the financial institution’s anti-money laundering division, who spoke on the situation of anonymity, stated Westpac relied on its correspondent financial institution companions to supply details about its shoppers. In different phrases, it is a one-way stream of knowledge. This makes it Euro Pacific’s accountability to make sure its shoppers aren’t concerned in prison exercise.

Westpac terminated its relationship with Euro Pacific in 2018 however received’t say why or present any particulars on how a lot cash it helped the financial institution transfer.

Euro Pacific is now on the hunt for a brand new Australian banking accomplice, telling prospects in July it will notify them “as quickly as incoming AUD transfers can be found once more”.

Schiff confronted

Schiff agreed to an interview final month. It occurred through Zoom from his upmarket residence exterior of New York. His guard was down. Within the 9 months because the J5’s raids, Euro Pacific’s identify had not leaked. Schiff began speaking about matters he’s comfy with – tax, the financial system, the wrongs of presidency spending.

Peter Schiff objects to reporter Nick McKenzie's line of questioning.

Peter Schiff objects to reporter Nick McKenzie’s line of questioning.Credit score:Channel 9

However the second he was requested about his Puerto Rican financial institution, he stiffened and distanced himself from its operations. Requested why his financial institution was caught up on the earth’s largest tax evasion probe, Schiff denied any wrongdoing, personally or by his financial institution.

“I am simply going to get out of this chair if you are going to preserve asking me these sorts of questions,” he stated.

Requested why the US Inner Income Service visited him on January 24, he refused to elaborate.

“I’ve already answered the query that we’re not concerned in any criminality,” he stated, including the financial institution “turns down way more accounts than we approve as a result of our compliance is so rigorous”.

Schiff threatened to sue this publication, ripped off his microphone and stormed out of his personal lounge.

Peter Schiff leaves the interview.

Peter Schiff leaves the interview.Credit score:Channel 9

Displace and chase

Chevis says concentrating on Euro Pacific is a thankless job. Shut down one financial institution and one other shortly fills its place.

“That’s the sport, you displace them and chase them to the following spot.”

Nonetheless, Chevis says, it’s price it.

“If Euro Pacific closes down, individuals are going to should go some other place … and hopefully a few of them simply received’t do it. Not less than, that’s what I inform myself.”


Day says Atlantis continues to maneuver in on the “professionals who may be eager about connecting their shoppers to those types of preparations”.

And he warns the Australians caught up within the probe could face civil penalties or jail phrases for tax evasion. Different Australian policing companies have joined the hunt. The nation’s peak prison intelligence company, the Australian Legal Intelligence Fee, has listed Euro Pacific as an Australian Precedence Organisation Goal. This designates it as one of the vital critical prison threats to the nation’s safety.

Schiff is dismissive of the curiosity from legislation enforcement.


“It is obtained nothing to do with actuality,” he says of Operation Atlantis. “There’s a variety of issues {that a} authorities may imagine which may not be true.”

And earlier than storming away, Schiff made it clear Euro Pacific goes nowhere.

“Now ultimately, I’m hoping that the financial institution can be worthwhile,” he stated.

If it does, it can buck the Greek fable after which Will Day’s and the J5’s operation is known as. The traditional story of Atlantis ends with the island sinking endlessly into the ocean.

Get our Morning & Night Version newsletters

A very powerful information, evaluation and insights delivered to your inbox at the beginning and finish of every day. Signal as much as The Sydney Morning Herald’s publication right here, The Age’s publication right here, Brisbane Instances‘ right here and WAtoday‘s right here.

Supply hyperlink

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.